Sometimes I feel like other parents think I’m a negligent mom.
My younger daughter’s in kindergarten and she burns off a lot of energy after school while we wait for her older sister to be dismissed – running, sliding, climbing and jumping. The last two are her favourites and now that winter has passed and she no longer has the padding of her snowsuit, skinned knees are a daily occurrence.
I’ve noticed that there aren’t that many kids her age around the school yard who are permitted to be quite as adventurous as I allow her to be.
“Don’t climb on that railing – your pretty clothes will get messy.”
“That is dangerous. Come down from there.”
Standing in line, along with the other parents to pick the kids up, I hear this all the time.
I have to admit, my heart does leap in my throat every time my 5 year-old clambers up the school’s chain-link fence. I also feel the judgement in the other parents’ eyes. And even when there are no witnesses, I’m often my own worst critic. The voice inside my head says, “She’s only 5. Should she be climbing a fence 5 times taller than her?” I have to hold myself back from yelling like all the other moms.
But my daughter has always been this way, always moving, always pushing her physical limits and I had to make a choice; I could either say no every 5 minutes or I could help my little one jump higher, longer, and learn to do it all as safely as possible. We talk about staying focused and holding strong, and the difference between jumping and falling. Of course this doesn’t mean that she’s never at risk of getting hurt. But I also know that as long as she’s not in danger of serious injury, I have to give her some freedom to develop and exercise her own judgement.
That doesn’t always work. Last year she fell down the stairs at home. Her broken arm was a lesson for me and for her, and a year later I see her making sure she has a grip on the railing as she walks up and down the stairs. Sliding down the railing though, shouting, “Look ma, no hands!” That’s another matter!
She’s my baby. I don’t want her to feel pain, and my heart speeds up until she lands on her feet.
For a while after the cast was removed I was one of the “Get down from there” moms and then I read an article from Active for Life in which Albi Sole of the Outdoor Council of Canada says that kids need to feel they are being adventurous, that they’re taking risks, and that it’s up to parents to make sure that their play feels adventurous without them actually being at risk for getting seriously hurt. They need this adventurous play to grow and develop properly.
My 5 year-old is living proof, and when I ask her why she likes to climb up the highest fence. Her response is simple,
“I like it because it’s not safe.”
So I’ve chosen to let my little girl feel like she’s taking risks, pushing her boundaries, and being adventurous. While she does that she’s also being active and that’s really important to me. Those kids that are always told no perhaps end up either choosing sedentary activities or taking risks when their parents are not around. I want to be around for the risky play so that I can help her learn, safely.
For me it’s worth it to withstand the judgmental looks in the playground, worth it to have to bite my own tongue, and worth it to be constantly assessing whether she’s in over her head or if she can handle whatever it is she’s taking on.
I’m not sure I’ll always know where the line is between her feeling adventurous and actually being in danger of getting more than a skinned knee. I’m keeping my fingers crossed and letting my gut guide me, and I also trust her to know her own limits. What I do know for sure is that I can’t say say no every time my 5 year-old wants to push herself. While that might feel safe, it just doesn’t feel right.
It’s hard to see them doing things that we think may hurt then, but I love that you’re letting her play and be herself. I grew up running, playing, climbing tree’s and I do think that we have gotten scared to let our kids be kids. It takes some of their joy away when we’re always saying no. Loved this post!
As a subscriber you will receive a fortnightly-ish newsletter about food, people and planet, and the stories and science behind it all. You'll also receive news about Maple + Marigold and Puneeta, as well as tasty recipes, health-boosting foods, sustainable swaps and tips to live well.
It’s hard to see them doing things that we think may hurt then, but I love that you’re letting her play and be herself. I grew up running, playing, climbing tree’s and I do think that we have gotten scared to let our kids be kids. It takes some of their joy away when we’re always saying no. Loved this post!
Thanks so much, Paula. Its a topic close to my heart with a 10 year old AND a 5 yo in the house there’s only so much No I can say 🙂
Goodness, yes! They need to learn their limits and how will they ever learn what those are if the adults are constantly stopping them from learning?
I love that you let her be a kid. Play is a kind of learning and a very important kind of learning at that!
Great post! Here’s to no casts, but many adventures! 😀
Yes, fingers crossed for an incident free summer!